Rule changes: Video evidence and reading greens

By
Updated: June 5, 2017

Video evidence of a rules violation no longer means a golfer automatically will be penalized. In an effort to limit the sometimes harsh result of television reviews, golf’s ruling bodies have issued a new decision on the Rules of Golf that takes effect immediately.

Players can avoid a penalty if the violation could not be noticed with the naked eye. Rules officials also will eliminate penalties if they feel players made a reasonable judgment in taking a drop or replacing their golf ball on the putting green.

Righting the wronged Lexi Thompson

Let’s start by tuning out the tattling viewers. While we’re at it, no more handing out penalties a day later. It’s time for the LPGA to take another pass at its rule book. And fast.

The new decision would have spared Anna Nordqvist a two-shot penalty that cost her a chance to win the U.S. Women’s Open last year.

It is unclear if the reasonable judgment standard noted in the announcement would have exonerated Lexi Thompson at the ANA Inspiration — the LPGA’s first major of the year — earlier this season.

Thompson was leading by two strokes on the back nine on April 2 when she received a four-stroke penalty — two for playing from an incorrect spot, and another two for signing an incorrect scorecard.

The infraction had occurred a day earlier, but officials were only alerted to it after being contacted via email by a TV viewer who noticed Thompson had incorrectly replaced her ball on a 1-foot putt on the 17th hole during the third round. She ended up losing in a playoff.

In 2016, the USGA and R&A had altered the rules to allow for a 2-stroke penalty in such scorecard signing situations if it was deemed the player could not have known about the penalty; prior to that, Thompson’s infraction would have resulted in disqualification.

The rules committee, after discussing the circumstances with the player and other members of the group, can now clear the player if it is determined that they did all that could be reasonably expected to make an accurate determination with a spot, a line of play or a drop.

In the announcement, both the USGA and R&A each made no mention of the rulings that affected those LPGA major championships, saying in a combined statement that it decided to enact this decision immediately because of the “many difficult issues arising from video review in televised golf.’’

New rule change could alter the way players read greens
The R&A and the USGA believe that a player’s ability to read greens is an essential part of the skill of putting.

Rule 14-3 limits the use of equipment and devices that might assist a player in their play, based on the principle that golf is a challenging game in which success should depend on the judgment, skills and abilities of the player.

We are concerned about the rapid development of increasingly detailed materials that players are using to help with reading greens during a round. We are reviewing the use of these materials to assess whether any actions need to be taken to protect this important part of the game.